Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Cinco De Mayo menu

30 dishes across 5 sections Mexican restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Cinco De Mayo photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

31st Street Menu - Power Plates* 8 dishes

  • Ultimate Plate US$15.95

    Brown rice, grilled chicken, mixed steamed vegetables and topped with hummus.

  • Chili Mexicana Plate US$15.38

    Brown rice, grilled chicken topped with chili.

  • The Riviera Salmon Plate US$19.11

    Grilled salmon, mixed steamed vegetables, brown rice with pico de gallo and salsa verde.

  • Lean & Ripped Chicken Plate US$14.65

    Mixed vegetables and and grilled chicken.

  • Mighty Jeff Ross Plate US$17.38

    Brown rice, chicken, chili beans, mozzarella cheese topped off with guacamole.

  • Lean Steak & Chipotle Bowl US$16.39

    Steak burger, grilled peppers and onions, guacamole, chili beans, brown rice and chipotle sauce.

  • Bob's Plate US$15.38

    Brown rice, grilled chicken topped with lentil.

  • Chicken Sweet Potato Plate US$12.66

    Grilled chicken breast with baked sweet potato.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Traditional Mexican Taco-Bar 1 dishes

  • Cinco De Mayo Taco Bar US$13.95

    MINIMUM 10 PEOPLE!!! $13.95 PER PERSON. Everything you need to make your own tacos. Choose up to 3 proteins. Includes: Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce, Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Beans (Black or Pinto), Mexican Yellow Rice, Guacamole, Cotija Mexican Powder Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Tortilla Chips, Sliced Limes, Diced Onions, Sour Cream, Cilantro, Tortillas (Soft Shell: Corn or Flour, Hard Shell: Corn Only)

31st Street Menu - Smoothies 4 dishes

  • Green Blast Smoothe US$8.34

    Pineapples, mangoes, bananas, kale, spinach, apple juice, ice.

  • Tropical Delight Smoothe US$7.65

    Pineapples, mangoes, strawberries, bananas, orange juice, ice.

  • Chocolate Banana PB Crunch Smoothe US$9.28

    Skim milk or almond milk, chocolate, whey protein, peanut butter, bananas and vanilla frozen yogurt.

  • Very Berry Smoothe US$8.34

    Strawberries, blueberries, apple juice, ice, vanilla frozen yogurt.

31st Street Menu - Desserts 5 dishes

  • Frosted Carrot Cake US$6.31

  • Flan Napolitana US$4.56

  • Protein Carrot Muffin US$4.00

  • Protein Brownie US$4.00

  • Carrot Cake US$4.29

31st Street Menu - - Catering Burritos Trays 1 dishes

  • Catering Burrito Trays US$109.95

    12" Tortilla, Mexican Yellow Rice, Beans (Black or Pinto), Lettuce, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Muenster Cheese. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering Salads 5 dishes

  • Catering Classic Vegetarian Salad US$105.00

    Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, falafel, lime, Feta cheese, olives, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.

  • Falafel Hummus Salad US$90.00

    Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, falafel, tomato, cucumber, romaine lettuce.

  • Catering Greek Salad US$95.00

    Serves 0-10 people. Feta, olives, lime, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.

  • Baked Tofu Hummus Salad US$100.00

    Serves 0-10 people. Hummus, baked tofu, tomato, cucumber, Romaine lettuce.

  • Chicken Guacamole Salad US$100.00

    Serves 0-10 people. Grilled chicken, guacamole, tomato, cucumber, romaine lettuce.

31st Street Menu - Salad 4 dishes

  • South American Taco Salad US$15.38

    Grilled chicken, brown rice, chili beans, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber, tomato, salsa, corn and Cheddar cheese.

  • Greek Salad With Chicken US$16.04

    Lettuce, grilled chicken, Feta cheese, olives lime, cucumber and tomato.

  • Salmon Salad US$18.67

    Grilled Salmon, romaine lettuce mix, pico de gallo, tomatoes & cucumbers.

  • Falafel Hummus Salad US$10.88

    Lettuce, falafel, hummus, tomato and cucumber.

31st Street Menu - Taco Salad 1 dishes

  • Taco Salad US$13.36

    Hard tortilla with lettuce, tomato, black or pinto beans, guacamole, Cotija cheese and sour cream.

31st Street Menu - Burrito or Burrito Bowl 2 dishes

  • Burrito Bowl US$12.95

    Flour or whole wheat tortilla, Mexican rice, black or pinto beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream & cheese.

  • Burrito US$12.95

    Flour or whole wheat tortilla, Mexican rice, black or pinto beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream & cheese.

31st Street Menu - Drink 5 dishes

  • Jarritos US$3.02

  • Mexican Coke US$3.54

  • Canned Soda US$1.99

  • Topo Chico US$3.54

  • Water US$1.99

31st Street Menu - Flautas 1 dishes

  • Flautas US$14.98

    4 fried rolled-up tortillas with chicken inside, comes with Salad, Sour cream and powdered cheese on top. Side of Rice and Beans included on the side.

31st Street Menu - Sides* 16 dishes

  • Mexican Rice US$4.03

  • Steamed Vegetables US$7.08

  • Brown Rice US$4.03

  • Pico De Gallo

  • Falafel US$4.34

  • Side Steamed Sweet Potato US$4.56

  • Sour Cream US$2.20

    2 oz.

  • Hummus US$2.79

  • Beans US$4.03

  • Guacamole

  • Salsa & Chips

  • Sweet Potato Fries US$3.79

  • Chips US$2.01

  • Guacamole & Chips

  • Salad US$4.65

  • French Fries US$3.79

31st Street Menu - Tostadas 2 dishes

  • Tostadas (2) US$10.43

    2 Fried Flat Tortillas containing black or pinto beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and powdered cheese.

  • Tostada (1) US$5.90

    1 Fried Flat Tortilla, containing black or pinto beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and powdered cheese.

31st Street Menu - Wraps & Burritos 6 dishes

  • Lazy Hustler Wrap Or Bowl US$12.85

    Bowl or whole wheat wrap, falafel, hummus, Romaine, tomato, cucumber, brown rice and chili beans topped with amari sauce.

  • Falafel Hummus Wrap US$10.67

    Whole wheat wrap, falafel, hummus, lettuce, cucumber and tomato topped with amari sauce.

  • Chicken Guacamole Wrap US$13.65

    Whole wheat wrap, grilled chicken, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber and tomato.

  • Greek Burger Wrap US$11.80

    Whole wheat wrap, sirloin burger, Feta pesto, lettuce, cucumber, tomato and onions topped with yogurt sauce.

  • South American Burrito US$13.79

    Whole wheat wrap or bowl, grilled chicken, brown rice, chili beans, guacamole, lettuce, cucumber and tomato.

  • The Pump Wrap US$16.25

    Double grilled steak and chicken guacamole with pico de gallo in a whole wheat wrap.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Desserts 6 dishes

  • Fruit Salad US$79.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Whole Frosted Protein Carrot Cake US$59.40

  • 12 Protein Carrot Muffins US$28.95

  • Flan Napolitano US$29.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • 35 Protein Mini Carrot Muffins US$17.50

  • Whole Protein Carrot Cake US$46.80

31st Street Menu - Quesadillas* 3 dishes

  • Cheese Quesadilla US$9.05

    Flour or whole wheat tortilla. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce, sour cream and salsa verde.

  • Quesadillas US$12.86

    Flour or whole wheat tortilla. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce, sour cream and salsa verde.

  • Quesabirria US$17.48

    Flour or Whole Wheat Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese Chopped Birria (Beef) mixed with Pico de Gallo *inside*. Sour Cream, Avocado Green Tomatillo Sauce and 4oz Birria Consome on the Side.

31st Street Menu - Tacos* 4 dishes

  • Birria Tacos (3) US$17.48

    6" corn tortilla, chopped birria, Muenster cheese and onions.

  • Tacos (3) US$12.86

    1. Choose Protein, 2. Choose Tortilla Style, 3. Choose Topping, 4. Choose extras if you like.

  • Taco (1) US$4.95

    1. Choose Protein, 2. Choose Tortilla Style, 3. Choose Topping, 4. Choose extras if you like.

  • Taquiza US$42.95

    10 Soft Tacos. Choose Your Protein (10 Grilled Chicken) or (10 Grilled Steak) or Both (5 & 5). Green and Red spicy sauce on side (Include utensils) ALL TOPPINGS MUST BE ON TOP, ON SIDE REQUEST WILL REPRESENT EXTRA CHARGE.

31st Street Menu - Homemade Mexican Drinks 3 dishes

  • Lemonade

  • Horchata

  • Jamaica

31st Street Menu - - Catering Taco Trays 2 dishes

  • Catering Taquiza US$36.65

    10 soft or hard corn tortilla tacos with a choice of protein and homemade tomatillo avocado sauce.

  • Catering Taco Tray US$109.95

    30 soft or hard corn tortilla tacos with a choice of protein and homemade tomatillo avocado sauce. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - - EVAS CATERING WRAPS/BURRITOS 6 dishes

  • Catering South American Burrito US$115.00

    Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, guacamole, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, whole wheat wrap.

  • Catering Mediterranean Burrito US$115.00

    Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, Feta pesto sauce, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, whole wheat wrap.

  • Catering The New Yorker US$120.00

    Serves 8-10 people. Grilled chicken, falafel, grilled tomato, onion, peppers, choice of humus or feta pesto, whole wheat wrap.

  • Catering The Greek Wrap US$110.00

    Serves 8-10 people. Sirloin burger, Feta pesto sauce, Romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, whole wheat wrap.

  • Catering Lazy Hustler Burrito US$115.00

    Serves 8-10 people. Falafel, hummus, Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, brown rice, chili beans, tahini sauce, whole wheat wrap.

  • Catering The Gennaro US$125.00

    Serves 8-10 people. 5 egg whites, tomato, sirloin burger, whole wheat wrap.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS CATERING POWER PLATES 8 dishes

  • Catering Bob’s Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, lentil soup, brown rice.

  • Catering Chili Mexicana Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, chili beans, brown rice.

  • Catering McMullan Power Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Baked tofu, steamed spinach, lentil soup, brown rice. Hummus on top.

  • Catering Lean & Ripped Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, steamed vegetables.

  • Catering Ultimate Plate US$140.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, vegetables, hummus, brown rice.

  • Catering Tony’s Plate US$130.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, tomato sauce, low fat Mozzarella, whole wheat pasta.

  • Catering Victory Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, steamed vegetables, brown rice.

  • Catering Grand Slam Plate US$120.00

    Serves 10-12 people. Grilled chicken, tomato sauce, tomato, onion, brown rice.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering Desserts 3 dishes

  • 12 Protein Carrot Muffins US$38.95

  • 35 Protein Mini Carrot Muffins US$14.95

  • Catering Eva’s Famous Carrot Cake US$42.00

    Serves 12-16 people. Frosting.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Quesadilla Trays 2 dishes

  • Catering Quesadilla Tray US$109.95

    12" Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese, Grilled Chicken (Pollo). On side: 28oz Plate (Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce) one of each.

  • Catering Cheese Quesadilla Tray US$99.95

    12" Tortilla. Melted Muenster Cheese, Grilled Chicken (Pollo). On side: 28oz Plate (Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream and Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce) one of each. (Serves 10-12 people)

31st Street Menu - Nachos 1 dishes

  • Nachos US$10.61

    Corn tortilla chips, beans, melted cheese, sour cream, jalapenos & tomato.

31st Street Menu - Cinco de Mayo Burgers 5 dishes

  • Queso Spicy Burger US$13.87

    Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

  • Bronx Quesadilla Burger US$12.13

    Fries, pico de gallo, guacamole, grilled onions and Muenster cheese.

  • Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe US$13.13

    Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

  • Cheeseburger Deluxe US$11.86

    Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

  • Hamburger Deluxe US$10.88

    Served with French fries, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mayo.

31st Street Menu - - EVAS Catering APPETIZERS 2 dishes

  • Catering Falafel With Hummus US$45.00

  • Catering Hummus With Corn Chips US$40.00

31st Street Menu - - Catering Sides 13 dishes

  • Catering Tray Of Beans US$19.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering Side - Guacamole And Corn Tortilla Chips Tray US$36.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28oz Avocado Tomatillo Green Sauce US$17.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28oz Pico De Gallo US$15.95

  • Catering Regular Salad Tray US$24.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering Side - Salsa And Corn Tortilla Chips Chips Tray US$27.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28 Oz Sour Cream US$16.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28oz Red Spicy Hot Sauce US$18.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering Side - Pico De Gallo And Corn Tortilla Chips US$29.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering Tray Of Rice US$24.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering Side - Corn Tortilla Chips Tray US$14.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28oz Salsa For Chips (Mild Sauce) US$14.68

    (Serves 8-10 people)

  • Catering 28oz Guacamole US$24.95

    (Serves 8-10 people)

31st Street Menu - Mexican Dishes 9 dishes

  • Mexican Chipotle Plate US$15.75

    Grilled steak and onions, Mexican rice, black beans, guacamole, cilantro, pico de gallo with chipotle sauce.

  • Cinco De Mayo Plate US$15.65

    Grilled chicken breast, chili beans, pico de gallo, salsa verde, Mozzarella cheese over brown rice or Mexican rice with guacamole.

  • Fried Pork Sauteed With Onions | Carnitas Encebolladas US$14.14

    Fried pork sauteed with onions, rice, pinto or black beans and guacamole.

  • Gym Bowl US$15.14

    Brown rice, black or pinto beans, pico de gallo, and grilled chicken topped with guacamole.

  • Chipotle Chicken Tinga | Tinga De Pollo US$15.14

    Shredded chicken breast on chipotle sauce with onions and tomatoes. Served with rice, pinto or black beans and guacamole.

  • Veggie Mex US$12.55

    Black or pinto beans over brown rice topped with guacamole and pico de gallo.

  • Triple Meat (Finest Bowl) US$16.13

    Finest meat. Mexican rice, black or pinto beans with chicken, steak, carnitas sauteed with pico de gallo.

  • Chicken Enchiladas US$15.65

    3 rolled up tortillas with chicken tomatillo sauce on top. Served with rice, black or pinto beans, sour cream, tomatoes, onions and lettuce.

  • Grilled Chicken Breast Plate US$13.85

    Mexican rice, black or pinto beans and guacamole.

31st Street Menu - - Catering Beverages 7 dishes

  • Catering Individual Mexican Coke (Crystal Bottle) US$3.85

  • Catering Individual Jarritos (Mexican Soda)

  • CATERING Poland Spring Bottled Water US$2.01

  • Catering 96oz Box. Home Made Lemonade US$24.95

  • Catering 96oz Box. Jamaica Mexican Drink US$24.95

  • Catering Canned Soda US$2.01

  • Catering 96oz Box. Horchata Mexican Drink US$24.95

31st Street Menu - Our Newest Additions 2 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken Guacamole Salad US$14.89

    Lettuce, corn, pico de gallo and guacamole.

  • California Burrito US$14.93

    Grilled steak, French fries, pico de gallo, Muenster cheese, sour cream and guacamole.

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in New York

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All New York listings
Menu Directions